Nothing completes a meal or soothes the soul better than an indulgent milkshake, and these NYC restaurants know how to craft these delectable desserts that taste just as incredible as they look.
Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beers serves up Instagram-worthy shakes that’ll have you posting them on social media all night! For something extra adventurous, try out one of their bacon shakes.
1. The Owl Cafe
The Owl Cafe is family-friendly, offering delicious milkshakes made with fresh ingredients in charming mason jars. Additionally, there is an extensive menu of desserts and beverages, reasonable pricing options, and free Wi-Fi access.
For those searching for something sweet to satisfy their sweet tooth, NYC offers many places specializing in milkshakes. Some restaurants may specialize in burgers; other locations even feature special milkshake-of-the-month offers!
Black Tap Craft Burgers and Beers has built its reputation on serving incredible milkshakes. In Midtown Manhattan, you’ve likely seen photos of their delicious treats on social media, such as Red Velvet Shakes or Chocolate Peanut Butter Shakes with Vanilla Iced Coffee as options!
The Brooklyn Farmacy and Soda Fountain offers another excellent milkshake spot. This cozy eatery pays homage to classic soda parlors of old with an extensive menu offering sundaes, shakes, frozen treats, and other frozen items made using high-quality ingredients, offering endless flavor combinations!
Oddfellows Ice Cream Shop in Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Queens offers something more unusual for ice cream fans. Their shakes may be slightly more costly than others but well worth their price: thick with chocolate peanut butter flavoring and lucky charms – you won’t be disappointed.
Petey’s Burger in Midtown Manhattan offers affordable dining at its burger joint. Choose from vanilla or strawberry shakes while watching your favorite team on TV. Don’t be put off by its name alone: this place also has plenty of TVs so friends can grab their drinks while watching games together!
2. Lola’s Cafe
This cafe specializes in offering thick and creamy shakes in stylish mason jars. Additionally, they serve food items like burgers and fries with plenty of toppings for their young clientele and hipsters alike. Their thick, creamy shakes come in unique flavors like fruit milkshakes, Oreo cookies, and chocolate!
Lower East Side residents will love this advanced roadside burgers and shakes version. Family-friendly, this restaurant provides a wide range of shakes and desserts with fresh ingredients for an authentic flavor experience. They even offer egg waffles topped with lots of frosting and decorative embellishments!
The owners of this milkshake joint sought to develop an entirely different experience with classic drinks. They aimed to improve upon them by adding flavor and making them healthier – using high-quality milk and natural ice cream, plus other nutritious ingredients to make their tasty drinks even tastier!
Finding a delicious milkshake in NYC may be simple, but selecting your preferred variety can be challenging. So many are so irresistibly good that choosing just one is tricky! One great advantage of a milkshake is its versatility: whether shared among friends or enjoyed alone on special occasions, milkshakes make an ideal treat!
Though the #coneonly movement may be on the rise, you should never let hot temperatures get in the way of enjoying an icy cold milkshake in New York. So grab your stainless steel reusable straw and enjoy one of these delightful cold beverages in this city that never sleeps!
3. Schnipper’s
Schnipper’s is an American fast-casual restaurant known for serving mouthwatering American fare such as juicy burgers, mac & cheese, sandwiches, salads, and milkshakes. The owners are incredibly proud to showcase the restaurant and all its distinct flavors and ingredients; their passion lies with high-quality fast casual dining experiences made fresh daily and serving their customer’s delicious food made from scratch!
The brothers behind this restaurant have spent considerable time traveling nationwide searching for traditional cooking. With this knowledge, they created a menu to please any taste or diet. With locations throughout New York City – such as Times Square, Flatiron District, Midtown East, and Financial District – these restaurants unite people by sharing healthy food and drinks.
Schnipper’s is known for offering a wide variety of sandwiches and salads for those who don’t enjoy burgers, making this an excellent option for vegetarians looking for satisfying, hearty meals without feeling deprived. Their delicious burgers include an exquisite classic featuring bacon, caramelized onions, baby arugula, and a special sauce for an unforgettable dining experience.
This restaurant also serves an indulgent milkshake with salted caramel flavor worth every calorie indulgence. Made with Gifford’s Ice Cream and an inviting amber hue, its salty aftertaste complements sweet caramel’s sweet notes perfectly – an irresistibly delicious treat you can share with family or friends alike! Make this restaurant part of your visit on a date night, or meet old acquaintances here.
4. Ben & Jerry’s
Cones may be the go-to dessert option this summer, but milkshakes near me in NYC offer just as satisfying an opportunity, if not more. Plus, they make for easy sharing!
Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain’s milkshakes provide the perfect sweet fix when searching for something sweet and unique. Inspired by vintage soda parlors, this charming vintage setting serves a selection of sundaes and milkshakes like the Black & White (vanilla ice cream with chocolate and vanilla whipped cream plus an espresso shot) or Rocket (vanilla custard layered between Doughnut Plant donuts, strawberry preserves and cinnamon sugar).
Shake Shack is another milkshake spot well worth checking out. While this burger joint may be best known for its disco fries, it also boasts fantastic shakes, such as its classic Harlem Shake, which features red velvet. They also offer other varieties, like their Tennessee Jed milkshake containing vanilla custard with bacon, smoked cheese, and bourbon!
Island Burgers and Shakes offer traditional milkshakes in Instagram-worthy glass jars for maximum preservation, featuring flavors like chocolate, vanilla, strawberry banana, and more! Their large portions can easily be shared between two people.
Lexington Candy Shop in the Upper East Side has been serving malt shakes since 1925 using their original machines – and they are still an absolute must for those who appreciate malt milkshakes! Their creamy and thick creations come with everything from Fruity Pebbles, Nerds Rope, Pop Tarts, and more for an experience you won’t soon forget!
5. Burgers N’ Shakes
Black Tap Craft Burgers and Beer is one of the city’s premier milkshake spots, renowned for their delectable creations that often appear on social media. Situated in Midtown Manhattan, they provide an extensive menu that ranges from elemental chocolate-rimmed shakes to those overflowing with candy – you’re sure to find something delicious here. Don’t forget their special Sugar Daddy Shakes – something your children may remember fondly from childhood memories!
This diner-style eatery is an iconic New York City fixture. Here, the food is of superior quality at reasonable prices, thus enabling visitors to indulge in a meal and shake without breaking the bank. Shakes make an ideal way to cap off an enjoyable dining experience and provide delicious dessert options!
If you prefer more classic milkshakes, look no further than Brooklyn Farmacy and Soda Fountain. This small cafe with retro appeal is ideal for relaxing with friends or family. Offering frosty consistency shakes in flavors such as vanilla, strawberry, and chocolate, plus extra toppings like peanut butter or caramel, can make for a beautiful treat!
OddFellows Ice Cream Shops in Manhattan, Queens, and Brooklyn provide another fantastic option. Their menu boasts several milkshake options – their most sought-after offering being their peanut butter cup shake. If desired, you can customize it further with toppings like caramel and graham cracker crumbs!
No one beats a creamy milkshake to satisfy that sweet craving! From classic flavors to outlandish creations, there will surely be one perfect milkshake spot in NYC that meets all your criteria. So grab your straw and head to one of these yummy milkshake joints today!
